News. Based on reporting by The Associated Press (published by WBUR and The Boston Globe) on the September change and the October 28 lawsuit, including statements from the plaintiffs and from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). GoImmigrant did not interview anyone for this article and has not reviewed the complaint itself.
For more than 15 years, families and lawyers have used ICE's Online Detainee Locator System to find out where a detained loved one is being held. Since mid-September, that tool has stopped showing the location of many people with final deportation orders. On Wednesday, October 28, immigrant legal service groups sued to reverse the change. Here's what is known, what it means for families in Illinois, and what you can still do.
What changed
According to The Associated Press, ICE removed detainees with final removal orders from the online locator on September 15. The AP based that on three current and former ICE officials who spoke on condition of anonymity, and several lawyers told the AP their clients had disappeared from the system that week. The American Immigration Lawyers Association warned its members about it.
ICE did not announce the change. In a statement to the AP, the agency did not confirm or deny it, and said detainees with final removal orders are being prioritized for deportation while ICE faces a "historic number of injunctions" from courts. As of September, the change affected more than 16,000 of the nearly 69,000 people in ICE custody, the AP reported.
A final removal order means an immigration judge ordered a person deported and the decision was upheld on appeal or not appealed. About 1.4 million people living in the U.S. are in that situation, according to the AP. The AP also notes that people with final orders can still have legal options, such as asking to reopen their case or challenging violations of their rights.
The Chicago exception, and its limits
The AP's sources said the change does not apply to people held at a detention center in Adelanto, California, or at temporary holding facilities in Minneapolis, New York City and suburban Chicago (The Boston Globe published the AP report). Judges have ordered ICE to list detainees at those facilities in the locator promptly after they arrive, as part of litigation over ICE's detention practices there. As reported, the exception is tied to those facilities. Detainees are frequently moved to new facilities, an immigration lawyers' group told the AP, and the AP report does not say the exception follows people who are moved elsewhere. We could not confirm whether it does.
The lawsuit
Four organizations that provide legal services to immigrants, including Greater Boston Legal Services, filed the case in federal court in Boston, the AP reported. They ask a judge to block what they call an "unlawful and inhumane" change. According to the AP's summary, the lawsuit says:
- Lawyers have been unable to find some clients and potential clients, and spend "significantly more time" tracking down others.
- Calls to ICE, including its Detention and Removal Information Line, "lead to long wait times on hold, sudden hang-ups, a general lack of information or no answer at all."
- The result has been delayed or missed legal filings and fewer cases taken.
- The change violates the Administrative Procedure Act because it was adopted without explanation, and the First Amendment, which protects lawyers' ability to advise people of their rights.
"No one should be denied a meaningful opportunity to defend their rights because the government has made it impossible for their lawyer to find them," said Jacquelynne Bowman, executive director of Greater Boston Legal Services.
DHS has denied that it is disappearing detainees and says they remain free to make phone calls. "Illegal aliens in detention have several ways to communicate with their family members and lawyers," DHS said in a statement responding to the lawsuit. "The appropriate process due to an illegal alien with final deportation orders is removal, plain and simple."
These are claims in a lawsuit that was just filed. As of Thursday morning, October 29, we found no report of a court ruling, so the change should be treated as still in effect.
If you can't find a loved one in the locator
This is general information, not legal advice.
- A missing result doesn't mean the person was deported or released. Under this change, a person with a final order may simply no longer be listed.
- Search more than one way. The locator lets you search by A-Number (the person's alien registration number) and country of birth, or by name and country of birth (date of birth may also be requested). For the A-Number search, ICE says the number must be nine digits; add zeros at the start if it is shorter. The locator cannot search for people under 18. Try both if you can, and write down the exact spelling you used.
- Get a lawyer or legal group involved right away. If the person has a final order, time can matter. A lawyer can tell you what options may still exist and how to try to locate them. See our list of free immigration legal help in Chicago.
- Keep records. Note every date you searched or called, who you spoke with and what you were told. That can help a lawyer later.
- ICE's list of detention facilities has contact information for each facility if you have an idea where the person may be.
Where to find help
- If someone is detained or to report ICE activity, call the ICIRR Family Support Hotline at 855-435-7693.
- Free legal help. Call the National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC) at 312-660-1370 (Tuesday to Thursday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Central).
This article is general information, not legal advice.