News. Based on reporting by NBC 5 Investigates, Telemundo Chicago and CBS News Chicago, and on public statements by the National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC), the Children's Legal Center and Sen. Dick Durbin's office. GoImmigrant did not attend the hearings or interview anyone for this article.
On October 29 and 30, about 90 immigrant children, some as young as 4, were scheduled to appear in Chicago Immigration Court over two days. Their lawyers say they had about a week's notice. Most of these kids came to the U.S. alone, and their lawyers say every one of them qualifies for a protection Congress created for abused, abandoned or neglected children. Here's what happened, what the government says, and what families caring for a child with an immigration case can do now.
What happened in court
- About 90 cases in two days. The Children's Legal Center, a Chicago nonprofit, had 45 cases scheduled for Thursday, October 29, and 45 more for Friday, NBC 5 Investigates reported. The cases were put on the calendar about a week earlier, giving the lawyers eight days to prepare. The court didn't finish Thursday's docket, so some cases were pushed to other days. The children live in Illinois, Wisconsin and Indiana.
- A judge on video from Texas. Texas-based Immigration Judge Susanna Martinez appeared by WebEx. According to NBC 5, she told a 15-year-old boy, "I'm going to have to send you back to Mexico," and also gave him the option to leave on his own. His lawyer, Children's Legal Center executive director Laura Smith, said she plans to appeal.
- Missed notices. One girl missed her hearing because her lawyers couldn't reach her in time, and the judge moved it to the following week. In another case, the lawyers said DHS mailed the child's Notice to Appear, the document that starts a deportation case, to an old address even though they had updated it, NBC 5 reported.
- "Mega master" hearings for kids. Lawyers use that name for hearings where many people appear at once. Smith and supervising attorney Brigitte Kocheny told NBC 5 they had never seen large-scale hearings like this for children. "I've never had cases move this quickly in immigration court," Kocheny said.
- The second day. About 45 more children came to court Friday, Telemundo Chicago reported. Instead of one by one, they were called in groups of four or five, and some waited hours before being told their cases would not be heard that day. Many cases were postponed to December 3. As of Friday, one child had received a deportation order, according to information shared at the hearings, and Jennifer Vázquez of the Children's Legal Center said it will be appealed.
Smith told Telemundo Chicago that one of her biggest fears is that a child who misses court after only seven days' notice could face deportation. She also told NBC 5 that children feel pressure to accept voluntary departure, which she called "almost like coercion because they don't fully understand the legal system."
A second courtroom: children sent from other states
The same day, October 29, CBS News Chicago reported that children from other parts of the country are being reassigned to Chicago Immigration Judge Shawn Abraham, who also appears by video. Kirby Tyrrell, a Washburn Law School professor who represents children from Kansas, said her clients' cases were moved to his docket with only a few days' notice. "We went from having several months, to having an actual update to provide to the court in March, to now suddenly having a week," she told CBS. The dozen cases CBS watched on October 29, involving children who appeared to be 6 to 16, were continued to dates one to two weeks later, and lawyers worry more children could be ordered deported then.
This has happened before. On August 26, Durbin and U.S. Rep. Mike Quigley watched juvenile hearings at the same court. NIJC said a judge appearing by video ordered nine of about 20 unaccompanied children deported that day, even though a state court had found they were abused, abandoned or neglected and they had applications pending for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status. Laura Smith said in NIJC's release that six of the children ordered removed that day were Children's Legal Center clients. The Chicago Sun-Times and CBS News Chicago reported six removal orders that day, for children 12 to 17, citing advocates and the hearing. The counts differ by source. NIJC also said that on July 31 the administration ended federal contracts that had paid for legal help for unaccompanied children. Durbin's office said thousands of children saw abrupt changes in their legal representation as a result.
What the government says
DHS told NBC 5: "ICE is not responsible for immigration attorneys taking on too many clients, or their poor time management." The statement said Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin is leading efforts to "find and rescue the 450,000 children lost by the prior administration," and it encouraged parents in the country illegally to leave using the CBP Home app.
In response to CBS's story about Judge Abraham, the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), which runs the immigration courts, said that it is "required to adjudicate all immigration cases in a timely manner," that prior leadership "may have allowed certain cases to languish indefinitely in violation of the law," and that it will keep adjusting schedules "to ensure all cases are handled in a timely and lawful manner." DHS told CBS it does not keep age-specific data on deportations.
What is Special Immigrant Juvenile Status?
According to USCIS, a child in the U.S. who needs the protection of a juvenile court because a parent abused, abandoned or neglected them may be eligible for Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) classification, which can lead to a green card. A state juvenile court has to make certain findings first, and the child has to apply to USCIS before turning 21. Even after approval, many children have to wait for a visa to become available before they can apply for a green card. Lawyers say the problem now is timing: immigration judges are moving forward with removal cases while those applications are still pending. In August, CBS News Chicago reported that Judge Abraham said the wait for visas was too long to justify letting the children stay; Smith said that until June, a pending application had meant the deportation case was closed.
If you care for a child with an immigration case
This is general information, not legal advice.
- Check the court date every week. Hearings can be moved earlier with little notice. Use the child's A-number (an A followed by 8 or 9 digits, printed on DHS and court papers; if it has 8 digits, put a 0 in front) on EOIR's Automated Case Information website, or call 1-800-898-7180, which gives case status in English and Spanish 24 hours a day, EOIR says.
- Keep the address up to date with the court. If the child moves, tell the court within five working days using Form EOIR-33/IC, on paper or online through EOIR's Respondent Access. Court notices sent to the old address still count. Updating the post office or USCIS does not update the court. If you have a lawyer, make sure they have your current phone number too.
- Don't miss a hearing. If a child doesn't show up, the judge can order them deported without them there. Calling the court does not move or excuse a hearing. If you can't get there, call the lawyer right away. If a child was ordered deported for missing court, a lawyer may be able to ask the court to reopen the case, but there are deadlines. For general questions, the Chicago Immigration Court's number is 312-220-0965.
- Talk to a lawyer before accepting "voluntary departure" or signing anything. Leaving can have long-term effects on a child's future options. Appeals also have short deadlines, so contact a lawyer as soon as there is a removal order.
Where to get free help
- National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC): For an unaccompanied child with a case in the Chicago or Indianapolis immigration court, NIJC says to text its free Immigration Court Helpdesk at 312-660-1328. If you don't have a lawyer, the Helpdesk also has walk-in help at the Chicago court (55 E. Monroe St., Suite 1500) on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, 8:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. NIJC's general line, 312-660-1370, is open Tuesday to Thursday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
- Children's Legal Center (Chicago nonprofit representing immigrant children): 312-722-6642 (English and Spanish), or see its website.
- ICIRR Family Support Hotline (statewide, if someone is detained or to report ICE activity): 855-435-7693.
- More options are on our free legal help in Chicago page.
We'll update this article if there are court rulings or new reports about these hearings.