Analysis. Based on a Bloomberg Law investigation published Nov. 9, 2026, the federal regulations that create the "automatic stay" (8 CFR 1003.19(i)(2) and 1003.6(c)–(d)), and ABC7 Chicago reporting on Nov. 9 and Nov. 10, 2026. DHS statements quoted here come from those outlets; GoImmigrant did not contact DHS or ICE for this article. This is general information, not legal advice.
For a family with someone in immigration detention, a bond hearing can feel like the finish line. The immigration judge listens, decides the person is not a danger and not likely to run, and sets a bond. Then, in some cases, nothing happens. The person stays locked up.
One reason is a little-known federal rule called the automatic stay. It lets the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) freeze a judge's release order simply by filing a notice of intent to appeal, Form EOIR-43, and then appealing. A Bloomberg Law investigation published Nov. 9 found the government has used it more than 900 times since January 2025 — compared with "a handful of times in the previous six years" — and that federal judges who rule on it are overwhelmingly rejecting it.
How the automatic stay works
The rule is in the federal regulations, and it is in effect now. Here is what the text says:
- Which cases. It applies when DHS had decided the person should not be released, or had set a bond of $10,000 or more, and an immigration judge then orders release (8 CFR 1003.19(i)(2)). Using it is up to DHS.
- One business day. DHS must file Form EOIR-43 with the immigration court within one business day of the judge's order. Once it does, the release order is on hold.
- Ten business days to appeal. The stay ends if DHS does not file an appeal with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) within ten business days of the judge's order. To keep the stay, DHS must file with its appeal a certification from a senior legal official that the appeal was approved and is supported by the evidence and the law (8 CFR 1003.6(c)).
- Up to 90 days — sometimes more. If the BIA has not decided the appeal, the stay lapses 90 days after DHS files it. That clock is paused if the detained person asks for, and gets, more time to file briefs. DHS can also ask the BIA for a separate, discretionary stay, and while that request is pending the hold can last up to 30 more days.
- Even after a win at the BIA. If the BIA orders release, or denies or does not act on a DHS request for a discretionary stay, release is held for five more business days. If DHS refers the case to the Attorney General in that time, the hold continues, and it expires 15 business days after the referral unless the Attorney General orders a further stay (8 CFR 1003.6(d)).
Bloomberg Law reports the rule was adopted on an emergency basis, without public comment, on Oct. 31, 2001, in the weeks after the Sept. 11 attacks, and that later administrations rarely used it. Kerry Doyle, whom Bloomberg Law identifies as deputy general counsel for homeland security in the Biden administration, told the outlet it was "like a nuclear option" kept for "the very worst cases."
What the numbers show
These figures come from Bloomberg Law's reporting. Except for the 889 figure, which comes from a Justice Department records response, they are Bloomberg Law's own count from court opinions, not official totals:
- A Justice Department response to a public-records request, obtained by journalist Paul Moses of the immigration news site Documented and shared with Bloomberg Law, showed 889 EOIR-43 filings in the first eight months of the second Trump administration. Bloomberg Law says the number has since passed 900, based on court opinions.
- Of 147 federal court cases on the automatic stay that reached a final opinion since January 2025, judges ordered the person freed 128 times, most often on due-process grounds. Judges found the stay lawful only five times; 14 did not reach a decision on the merits.
- Federal judges have issued more than 270 orders blocking the government in advance from using the automatic stay if bond is granted.
Bloomberg Law built its count from about 750 federal court opinions found by keyword search through Oct. 31, 2026, sorted with help from an AI model and checked by reporters on a random sample. Bloomberg Law says the Executive Office for Immigration Review, the Justice Department agency that runs the immigration courts, declined to expedite its public-records request for the number of EOIR-43s filed in the last 12 months.
Bloomberg Law also reports that use of the stay has slowed in recent months in some places, and that it is unclear whether that is because judges keep rejecting it or because fewer people are being granted bond in the first place.
What judges — and DHS — say
Judges appointed by presidents of both parties have ruled against the practice. Closer to home, Senior U.S. District Judge Sarah Evans Barker in the Southern District of Indiana, a Reagan appointee, wrote in a 2025 decision, as quoted by Bloomberg Law, that "there is no legal authority—save for the existence of the regulation itself—to support the government's position that the regulation was lawful."
Not every judge agrees. Bloomberg Law found five rulings upholding the stay; three pointed to the executive branch's broad power over immigration enforcement. Government lawyers have argued that bond decisions are not final until the BIA hears the appeal. In an April 2, 2026, brief, Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Puskar wrote that an immigration judge setting a bond amount "does not mean that a final, operative decision on bond has been reached by the attorney general."
DHS did not answer Bloomberg Law's detailed questions. In a statement, it called the automatic stay a "tool" it is legally entitled to use: "We will never apologize for or hesitate to use legally available tools to enforce the law and defend the homeland."
Why this matters in the Chicago area
People arrested in Illinois are often held far from home, in Indiana, Kentucky and other states. On Nov. 9, ABC7 Chicago reported that an immigration judge had ordered Beata Siemionkowicz — a green card holder from Poland who lived in Round Lake and was arrested by ICE in Des Plaines in August 2025 — released on bond after about 15 months in custody in Kentucky. She stayed detained while DHS had what ABC7 called "24 business hours" to challenge the order. ABC7 did not say what rule set that window; it resembles the one-business-day deadline DHS has to file Form EOIR-43 under the automatic-stay rule. DHS would not tell ABC7 whether it would challenge. On Nov. 10, ABC7 reported that her attorney said ICE is allowing the family to post bond. ABC7 reported that the judge's decision does not change the deportation order against her; release would let her keep fighting it from home.
ABC7 did not report that DHS filed Form EOIR-43 in her case, and GoImmigrant has not seen her court records, so we do not know whether the automatic stay applied to her. The rule covers only cases where DHS had refused release or set a bond of $10,000 or more. Still, cases like hers show why the first business day after a bond hearing can matter.
This is a separate fight from the one the U.S. Supreme Court agreed in October to decide: whether ICE can hold many people without any bond hearing at all. We explained that case, and what the Seventh Circuit's July 2026 ruling means for people held in Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin, in our Oct. 17 article. The automatic stay comes into play after a bond hearing has happened and the person has won.
If a judge grants bond and your loved one is not released
General questions families can raise with a lawyer — every case is different:
- Ask the lawyer whether DHS filed Form EOIR-43 and, if so, whether it filed its BIA appeal within ten business days. Under the rule, the stay ends if it did not.
- Keep the paperwork. Save a copy of the judge's bond order and any notices, and write down dates. The deadlines in the rule run from those dates.
- Ask about federal court. Many detained people have challenged the automatic stay by filing a habeas corpus petition in federal district court. Bloomberg Law's numbers show many have won, but results depend on the court and the facts, and it takes a lawyer.
- If ICE will not accept the bond, tell the lawyer right away. Bloomberg Law describes cases where families were turned away even after a stay had ended or a federal judge had ordered release.
- Find the person. Use the ICE Online Detainee Locator — and read our report on what it may not show.
- Free legal help. See our list of free immigration legal help in Chicago, or call the National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC) at 312-660-1370 (Tuesday to Thursday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Central).
- Report a detention or get help. The ICIRR Family Support Hotline is 855-435-7693.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For help with your own situation, talk to a qualified immigration attorney or a DOJ-accredited representative.